November 17, 2026
0_PIC-EMBARGOED-UNTIL-7TH-MARCH-2024Steve-RotheramMetro-Mayor-of-Liverpool-City-Regionleftw.jpg

Steve Rotheram, Mayor of Liverpool City Region, writes for the Mirror about how Labour must reform the welfare state so it gives people ‘security, dignity and the chance of a better life’

I have never believed that defending the welfare state means preserving it in aspic.

I’m proud of what Labour built. A safety net when life deals people a bad hand. Security and dignity for those who cannot work. And nobody condemned to poverty by the postcode they were born in. But we don’t honour those principles by defending a system that’s failing the people it was built to help.

We’ve now got a system that’s too quick to tell young people what they can’t do, and nowhere near good enough at helping them achieve what they can.

I know because my own options seemed limited at 16. I grew up in Kirkby, one of eight kids. My dad drove a forklift truck and I wasn’t exactly tipped for academic greatness! But a bricklaying apprenticeship gave me a trade, my first wages and opened doors I never knew existed. I certainly didn’t expect to become an MP, then mayor.

That first chance changed my life. Yet nearly a million young people are out of education, employment or training, without the chance to discover what they’re capable of.

To see more of the stories you love from The Mirror and to find them easily in Google then make us your preferred source. Free and easy-to-do, just click on the link here to find more from The Mirror at the top of your feed.

For years, we’ve watched youth services disappear, mental health support stretched and opportunities dry up in communities already struggling. Then we act surprised when young people find themselves out of luck, out of hope and out of work. There’s nothing progressive about accepting that.

I understand why some Labour colleagues are nervous when they hear ‘welfare reform’. Under the Conservatives, we saw cuts dressed up as compassion, with the poorest and most vulnerable left to pick up the pieces.

I opposed that approach then, and I don’t support it now. People who cannot work must always have security and dignity. Nobody should be punished for being ill or disabled.

But here’s the question we have to ask ourselves as Labour people: if the system is failing so many young people, how can leaving it untouched possibly be the compassionate answer?

The Conservatives spent years trying to make the welfare state cheaper, decimating Sure Start, closing children’s centres and slashing youth provision. Labour’s job should be to make it better. That’s the difference between cutting support and creating opportunity.

That’s why I welcome Alan Milburn’s review. Rather than simply picking up the pieces when things go wrong, it makes the case for investing in people’s potential early, giving them the support and opportunities to succeed.

Its proposed Youth Opportunity Service could bring together health, skills and employment support, giving young people somebody in their corner rather than passing them between departments.

See also  Cowardly killers who refuse to attend sentencing face more punishment in jail in Mirror campaign win

It’s the approach we’re taking in the Liverpool City Region through our Youth Guarantee trailblazer. For us, the answer isn’t the Tories’ sanctions-first approach. It’s practical, wraparound support to help young people get on.

Give mayors the powers and resources to go further, judge us on the results and hold us accountable if we don’t deliver.

Of course, taxpayers’ money must be spent responsibly. But if we judge success simply by what we’ve saved, we’ve missed the point. Success means more young people earning, learning and building better lives.

Labour didn’t create the welfare state simply to manage poverty. We created it to give people security, dignity and the chance of a better life.

We shouldn’t be afraid to change a system that’s failing to deliver that promise. We should be afraid of leaving it as it is.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *